Interest-Only vs. Capital Repayment Mortgages: A Comprehensive Comparison

Please note: This blog is for general information only and does not constitute advice. The information is aimed at retail clients only. You should always seek professional advice from an appropriately qualified adviser.

All contents are based on our understanding of current legislation, which is subject to change, any information provided here is only correct at the time of posting. 

The Financial Conduct Authority do not regulate will writing, loans, credit cards or some forms of mortgage, tax advice, offshore investments and estate planning.

---

Choosing the right mortgage is a critical decision. Two of the most common mortgage types are interest-only mortgages and capital repayment mortgages. Each has its unique characteristics, advantages, and drawbacks. In this comprehensive comparison, we'll delve into the differences between these two mortgage types to help you make an informed choice.

Interest-Only Mortgage

An interest-only mortgage, as the name suggests, allows borrowers to pay only the interest on the loan during the mortgage term. The principal amount borrowed remains constant throughout the mortgage period. Here are the key features of an interest-only mortgage:

1. Lower Monthly Payments: One of the primary attractions of interest-only mortgages is that they offer significantly lower monthly repayments compared to capital repayment mortgages. This can be particularly appealing for borrowers looking to maximise their cash flow in the short term. 

2. Separate Savings Vehicle: Borrowers with interest-only mortgages are typically required to set up a separate savings or investment plan to repay the principal at the end of the mortgage term. This could involve investments such as stocks, bonds, or an Individual Savings Account (ISA). This is far riskier than opting for a repayment mortgage, where you know your payments will completely. 

3. Potential for Investment Gains: Since you're not making regular principal payments, you have the opportunity to invest your money elsewhere. If your investments perform well, you may end up with a surplus that can be used to pay off the mortgage balance or for other purposes. Although, of course, things can go the other way, and if your investment performs badly, you may not have enough to repay the borrowing.

4. Risk of Negative Equity: One of the significant risks associated with interest-only mortgages is the potential for negative equity. If your investments perform poorly or you fail to save enough to repay the principal, you may owe more than your property is worth when it's time to repay the mortgage.

5. Interest Costs: Despite the lower monthly repayments, as the original amount borrowed remains constant, you will pay significantly more in interest costs over the mortgage term than a capital repayment mortgage.

Capital Repayment Mortgage

A capital repayment mortgage, also known as a repayment mortgage, is the more traditional and straightforward option. With this type of mortgage, you make monthly payments that cover both the interest on the loan and a portion of the principal. Over time, the balance of the loan decreases until it is fully paid off by the end of the mortgage term. Here are the key features of a capital repayment mortgage:

1. Principal Reduction: With each monthly payment, you are chipping away at the principal amount borrowed. Over time, this results in a significant reduction in your mortgage balance.

2. Predictable Equity Buildup: Capital repayment mortgages provide a clear path to homeownership, as you know that by the end of the term, you will have fully repaid the loan, and the property will be entirely yours.

3. Higher Monthly Payments: Monthly payments for capital repayment mortgages are typically higher than those for interest-only mortgages. This can put more strain on your monthly budget, especially in the early years of the mortgage.

4. Limited Cash Flow: While you're building equity, your monthly payments may leave you with less disposable income compared to interest-only mortgages, potentially impacting your ability to invest or save for other financial goals.

Comparison

Now, let's compare interest-only and capital repayment mortgages in key areas:

1. Monthly Payments:

•    - Interest-Only: Lower monthly payments, offering short-term financial relief.

•    - Capital Repayment: Higher monthly payments, reducing the principal and increasing equity.

2. Equity Buildup:

•    - Interest-Only: No automatic reduction in the principal; relies on separate savings or investments.

•    - Capital Repayment: Steady buildup of equity as the principal is gradually paid down.

3. Risk:

•    - Interest-Only: Higher risk of negative equity if investments underperform or savings fall short.

•    - Capital Repayment: Lower risk as the mortgage balance reduces over time, ensuring you eventually own the property outright. 

4. Suitability

•    - Interest-Only: May be suitable for borrowers with irregular income, strong investment opportunities, or a clear repayment plan.

•    - Capital Repayment: Suitable for those seeking predictable homeownership and willing to commit to higher monthly payments.

 5. End-of-Term Scenario

•    - Interest-Only: Requires a lump-sum payment or the sale of the property to repay the principal.

•    - Capital Repayment: No additional payments required; you own the property outright.

Conclusion

Choosing between an interest-only mortgage and a capital repayment mortgage depends on your financial situation, risk tolerance, and long-term goals. Interest-only mortgages offer lower initial monthly payments and the potential for investment gains but come with the risk of negative equity and higher overall interest costs over the term of the mortgage. On the other hand, capital repayment mortgages provide a predictable path to homeownership, with higher monthly payments but lower long-term risk.

Ultimately, the decision should be based on your individual circumstances and financial plan. It's advisable to consult with a mortgage adviser or financial planner to assess which mortgage type aligns better with your goals and helps you achieve your homeownership dreams while managing your financial responsibilities effectively.